I have been to Pupatella 5ish times in the past couple of months which means I am pretty much in love with this place (time 1, time 2... and other random times with no photos). My uncle was in town for business and he was in the mood for pizza so I suggested Pupatella.
We decided to split an appetizer because they told us it would come out quicker then the pizza (very busy that night) so we ordered a sampler. It was good, nothing spectacular.
4/5 times I have been here I have gotten the Prosciutto and Arugula Pizza. Great every time, can't seem to go outside my box here, this is probably my favorite topping on pizza.
Uncle ordered the Pepperoni Pizza + Onions for an extra $1. He enjoyed his pizza/this combo.
The 5th time I went, you guessed it, ordered the Prosciutto and Arugula again and it was awesome as usual.
Also tried the Prosicoutto and Arugula salad, good, basically the pizza I love in salad form.
Pupatella has now taken over the store next to them and expanded their seating area. While their food quality is still awesome, the time it takes to get a pizza is slacking. It took about an hour for us to get both of our pizzas, double the time they said it would take. Hopefully the time problem is just due to new expansion.
The most recent time it appeared that they have gotten a better hang of the whole timing process. We got everything in a reasonable amount of time for it being a Saturday night.
As I have said before, go to Pupatella...you will not be disappointed!!!